Article 142: Complete Justice by the Supreme Court – Notes with PYQs

Article 142: Complete Justice by the Supreme Court – Notes with PYQs

Article 142 gives the Supreme Court a special power: to pass any order needed to do "complete justice" in a case before it. The Court has used it to settle the Bhopal gas case, grant divorces, give land in the Ayodhya case and even declare the winner of a mayor's election. Because the power is so wide, it is also criticised as a tool for judicial overreach. This post explains Article 142, its limits and the main cases in simple words. It ends with 15 previous year questions.

Key Points (Quick Revision)

  • Article 142(1) - the Supreme Court can pass any decree or order necessary for complete justice in any case pending before it.
  • Such orders are enforceable throughout India.
  • The power belongs only to the Supreme Court, not to High Courts.
  • Limit: it cannot be used to override substantive law or ignore express statutory provisions (Supreme Court Bar Association case, 1998).
  • In 2023, a Constitution Bench held that the Court can grant divorce on irretrievable breakdown of marriage under Article 142.

1. What Article 142 says

ClauseProvision
142(1)The Supreme Court may pass any decree or make any order necessary for doing complete justice in any cause or matter pending before it. It is enforceable throughout India as provided by a law of Parliament or, until then, an order of the President.
142(2)Subject to any law of Parliament, the Court has full power to secure the attendance of any person, the discovery or production of documents, and to punish for contempt of itself.

The phrase "complete justice" lets the Court fill gaps where existing law does not give a full remedy.

2. Related Articles

  • Article 129 - the Supreme Court is a court of record and can punish for its contempt.
  • Article 141 - the law declared by the Supreme Court is binding on all courts in India.
  • Article 144 - all civil and judicial authorities in India shall act in aid of the Supreme Court.
  • Article 32 - the right to move the Supreme Court for enforcement of Fundamental Rights.

Together, these make the Supreme Court's orders effective across the country.

3. Landmark uses of Article 142

CaseYearWhat the Court did
Union Carbide v. Union of India (Bhopal gas case)1991Upheld the 1989 settlement of $470 million between Union Carbide and the Government of India
Vineet Narain v. Union of India1997Laid down guidelines to make the CBI and the CVC more independent
Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan1997Gave guidelines on sexual harassment at the workplace until Parliament made a law (2013)
State of Tamil Nadu v. K. Balu2016Banned liquor sale within 500 metres of national and state highways
M. Siddiq v. Mahant Suresh Das (Ayodhya)2019Directed that 5 acres of land be given for a mosque
Kuldeep Kumar v. UT Chandigarh2024Set aside the mayor election result and declared the rightful winner after ballot tampering

4. Divorce under Article 142 (2023)

In Shilpa Sailesh v. Varun Sreenivasan, decided on 1 May 2023, a five-judge Constitution Bench held:

  • The Supreme Court can grant a divorce by mutual consent without the six-month waiting period under the Hindu Marriage Act, in suitable cases.
  • The Court can dissolve a marriage on the ground of irretrievable breakdown, even though this is not a ground in the Hindu Marriage Act.
  • This power is used with care, after looking at factors such as the length of separation and failed attempts at settlement.

Only the Supreme Court can do this under Article 142; family courts and High Courts cannot.

5. Limits on the power

  • Prem Chand Garg v. Excise Commissioner (1962) - an order under Article 142 cannot go against Fundamental Rights.
  • Supreme Court Bar Association v. Union of India (1998) - Article 142 cannot be used to supplant substantive law. The Court cannot suspend an advocate's licence, which is a power of the Bar Council under the Advocates Act.
  • Orders must not ignore express provisions of a statute dealing with the same subject.
  • In November 2025, the Court said in a Presidential Reference opinion that Article 142 cannot be used to grant "deemed assent" to Bills in place of the Governor or President.

6. Debate: complete justice or overreach?

Supporters sayCritics say
It fills gaps in law and gives relief where no other remedy existsIt lets judges act like lawmakers, against the separation of powers
It helped protect rights - for example, the Vishaka guidelinesThere are no clear standards for when it will be used
It allows quick final settlement of long disputesOrders like the highway liquor ban had big economic effects without debate in a legislature

The Court itself has said the power must be used sparingly and with restraint.

7. Article 142 vs other powers

PowerArticleWho has it
Complete justice142Supreme Court only
Writs for Fundamental Rights32Supreme Court
Writs for Fundamental Rights and other rights226High Courts
Special leave to appeal136Supreme Court
Advisory opinion143Supreme Court, on the President's reference

8. Previous year questions

  1. Which Article of the Constitution empowers the Supreme Court to do complete justice? – Article 142
  2. Can a High Court exercise power under Article 142? – No, only the Supreme Court
  3. Under Article 142(2), the Supreme Court can punish for what? – Contempt of itself
  4. Which Article makes the law declared by the Supreme Court binding on all courts? – Article 141
  5. Which Article requires all authorities to act in aid of the Supreme Court? – Article 144
  6. Which Article declares the Supreme Court a court of record? – Article 129
  7. Which case upheld the Bhopal gas settlement using Article 142? – Union Carbide v. Union of India (1991)
  8. Which 1998 case held that Article 142 cannot supplant substantive law? – Supreme Court Bar Association v. Union of India
  9. Which 2023 case allowed divorce on irretrievable breakdown under Article 142? – Shilpa Sailesh v. Varun Sreenivasan
  10. How much land did the Supreme Court direct to be given for a mosque in the Ayodhya case? – 5 acres
  11. Which case gave guidelines on sexual harassment at the workplace? – Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan (1997)
  12. Within what distance of highways did the Supreme Court ban liquor sale in 2016? – 500 metres
  13. Which case gave guidelines to make the CBI more independent? – Vineet Narain v. Union of India (1997)
  14. Which case held that an order under Article 142 cannot violate Fundamental Rights? – Prem Chand Garg case (1962)
  15. Which Article gives the Supreme Court power to grant special leave to appeal? – Article 136

9. How to revise this topic

Start with the text: 142(1) complete justice, enforceable across India; 142(2) attendance, documents, contempt. Link it with Articles 129, 141 and 144.

Next, learn the landmark uses: Union Carbide 1991, Vineet Narain 1997, Vishaka 1997, K. Balu 2016, Ayodhya 2019, Chandigarh mayor 2024.

Then fix the 2023 divorce ruling: Shilpa Sailesh, 1 May 2023, five judges, irretrievable breakdown, six-month wait can be waived.

Finally, remember the limits: Prem Chand Garg 1962, Supreme Court Bar Association 1998, and the November 2025 opinion on no deemed assent.

10. Frequently Asked Questions

What is Article 142?

Article 142 allows the Supreme Court to pass any decree or order necessary for doing complete justice in any case before it. Such orders are enforceable throughout India.

Can High Courts use Article 142?

No. The power under Article 142 belongs only to the Supreme Court.

What are the limits of Article 142?

The Court has held that Article 142 cannot be used against Fundamental Rights or to override substantive law and express statutory provisions on the same subject.

Can the Supreme Court grant divorce under Article 142?

Yes. In 2023, a five-judge Bench held that the Supreme Court can dissolve a marriage on the ground of irretrievable breakdown and can waive the six-month waiting period for mutual consent divorce in suitable cases.

Why is Article 142 criticised?

Critics say it lets the Court act like a lawmaker without clear standards, which may go against the separation of powers. The Court has said the power must be used sparingly.

For more Polity topics in simple language, see our Judicial Review and PIL, Writs and Governor's Assent to Bills posts, or browse the Polity section. Preparing for judicial or civil services? Start with the UPSC Civil Services guide or join the 100 Hour GS Course.