Governor's Assent to Bills: Articles 200 and 201 – Notes with PYQs

Governor's Assent to Bills: Articles 200 and 201 – Notes with PYQs

A Bill passed by a State Legislature becomes a law only after the Governor gives assent, or after the President gives assent to a Bill reserved by the Governor. Article 200 and Article 201 of the Constitution set out these powers. In recent years, several States complained that Governors kept Bills pending for months or years. This led to important Supreme Court rulings in 2023 and 2025, and a Presidential Reference. This post explains it all in simple words. It ends with 15 previous year questions.

Key Points (Quick Revision)

  • Article 200 - options of the Governor on a State Bill: assent, withhold, return (not a Money Bill), or reserve for the President.
  • Article 201 - options of the President on a Bill reserved by the Governor.
  • April 2025 - in the Tamil Nadu case, a two-judge Bench set timelines and treated ten Bills as having received assent.
  • May 2025 - the President sought the Supreme Court's opinion under Article 143.
  • 20 November 2025 - a five-judge Bench said courts cannot fix timelines and there is no "deemed assent", but long, unexplained delay can be reviewed.

1. Article 200: options of the Governor

When a Bill passed by the State Legislature is presented to the Governor, the Governor can:

  1. Give assent - the Bill becomes law.
  2. Withhold assent - the Bill does not become law.
  3. Return the Bill (if it is not a Money Bill) with a message asking the House to reconsider it. This should be done "as soon as possible". If the House passes it again, with or without changes, the Governor shall not withhold assent.
  4. Reserve the Bill for the President.

The Governor must reserve a Bill that would reduce the powers of the High Court so as to endanger its constitutional position.

2. Article 201: options of the President

  • For a Bill reserved by the Governor, the President can give assent or withhold assent.
  • For a Bill that is not a Money Bill, the President can direct the Governor to return it to the House for reconsideration.
  • The House must reconsider it within six months. If passed again, it goes back to the President, who is not bound to give assent.
PointGovernor (Art. 200)President (Art. 201)
Return a re-passed Bill again?No - must assent (or reserve)Not bound to assent
Time limit in the text"As soon as possible" for returnSix months for the House to reconsider
Money BillCannot be returnedCannot be returned

For Bills passed by Parliament, the President's options are in Article 111. Since no time limit is given there, the President can use a pocket veto - as with the Indian Post Office (Amendment) Bill in 1986.

3. Does the Governor act alone?

Under Article 163, the Governor normally acts on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister, except where the Constitution allows discretion.

  • Shamsher Singh case (1974) - the President and Governors are constitutional heads who generally act on ministerial advice.
  • Nabam Rebia case (2016) - the Governor's discretion is limited and must be used only where the Constitution clearly allows it.

Reserving a Bill for the President is one area where the Governor can use some discretion. The extent of this discretion was a key question in the recent cases.

4. The Punjab case (2023)

In State of Punjab v. Principal Secretary to the Governor of Punjab, decided in November 2023, the Supreme Court said:

  • A Governor cannot keep Bills pending indefinitely.
  • If the Governor decides to withhold assent, the Bill must be returned to the Legislature for reconsideration.
  • The Governor, as an unelected head, cannot block the work of an elected Legislature.

5. The Tamil Nadu judgment (April 2025)

In State of Tamil Nadu v. Governor of Tamil Nadu, decided on 8 April 2025, a two-judge Bench of the Supreme Court:

  • Held that the delay in acting on ten Bills was unconstitutional.
  • Used its special power under Article 142 to treat these ten Bills as having received assent ("deemed assent").
  • Set timelines - for example, one month or three months, depending on the action - for Governors, and three months for the President on reserved Bills.

This was the first time the Court set time limits for the President and Governors on Bills. It led to a wide debate on separation of powers.

6. The Presidential Reference and the November 2025 opinion

On 13 May 2025, the President sought the Supreme Court's opinion under Article 143(1), raising 14 questions on Articles 200 and 201. A five-judge Constitution Bench gave its opinion on 20 November 2025:

QuestionOpinion of the Court
Can courts fix timelines for Governors and the President?No. The Constitution gives no fixed time limit, and courts cannot add one.
Is "deemed assent" valid?No. Article 142 cannot be used to give assent in place of the Governor or President.
Can courts review a decision on a Bill before it becomes law?No. The merits of the decision are not open to review at that stage.
What if the Governor simply sits on a Bill?Prolonged, unexplained and indefinite inaction can be reviewed. The court can direct the Governor to act within a reasonable time, but cannot decide the outcome.
Must the President seek the Court's advice on every reserved Bill?No.

An opinion under Article 143 is advisory. But it carries great weight, and it has changed how the April 2025 timelines are understood.

7. Article 143: advisory jurisdiction

  • Under Article 143(1), the President can refer any question of law or fact of public importance to the Supreme Court for its opinion. The Court may give or refuse its opinion.
  • Under Article 143(2), disputes on pre-Constitution treaties can be referred; here the Court must give its opinion.
  • Such references are heard by a Bench of at least five judges (Article 145(3)).
  • Famous earlier references include the Kerala Education Bill (1958), Berubari (1960) and the Third Judges case (1998).

In the 1993 Ayodhya reference, the Court declined to answer - showing that answering is not compulsory under Article 143(1).

8. Previous year questions

  1. Which Article deals with the Governor's assent to State Bills? – Article 200
  2. Which Article deals with Bills reserved for the President's consideration? – Article 201
  3. Which type of Bill cannot be returned by the Governor for reconsideration? – Money Bill
  4. Which Bill must the Governor reserve for the President? – A Bill that endangers the position of the High Court
  5. Within how many months must a State Legislature reconsider a Bill returned on the President's direction? – Six months
  6. Which Article deals with the President's assent to Bills passed by Parliament? – Article 111
  7. Which Bill is a famous example of the President's pocket veto? – Indian Post Office (Amendment) Bill, 1986
  8. Under which Article does the Governor act on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers? – Article 163
  9. Which Article gives the President the power to seek the Supreme Court's advisory opinion? – Article 143
  10. Under which Article did the Supreme Court grant 'deemed assent' in April 2025? – Article 142
  11. How many Bills were deemed to have received assent in the Tamil Nadu case (2025)? – Ten
  12. On which date did the Supreme Court give its opinion on the Presidential Reference on assent to Bills? – 20 November 2025
  13. How many questions were raised in the 2025 Presidential Reference? – 14
  14. Is the Supreme Court bound to give an opinion under Article 143(1)? – No
  15. Which case held that the President and Governors generally act on ministerial advice? – Shamsher Singh case (1974)

9. How to revise this topic

Start with the Articles: 200 (Governor's four options), 201 (President on reserved Bills, six months), 111 (Parliament Bills, pocket veto 1986), 163 (aid and advice), 143 (advisory opinion), 142 (complete justice).

Next, learn the cases in order: Shamsher Singh 1974, Nabam Rebia 2016, Punjab November 2023, Tamil Nadu 8 April 2025.

Then fix the Reference: 13 May 2025, 14 questions, five-judge opinion on 20 November 2025.

Finally, remember the opinion: no court-fixed timelines, no deemed assent, but limited review of prolonged, unexplained inaction.

10. Frequently Asked Questions

What are the options of a Governor on a State Bill?

Under Article 200, the Governor can give assent, withhold assent, return a non-Money Bill for reconsideration, or reserve the Bill for the President.

Can a Governor keep a Bill pending forever?

No. The Supreme Court has said that Governors cannot sit on Bills indefinitely. In November 2025, it said prolonged, unexplained inaction can be reviewed, and the court can direct the Governor to act.

What is deemed assent?

Deemed assent means treating a Bill as having received assent without the Governor actually signing it. The Supreme Court used it in April 2025, but the November 2025 opinion said it is not valid.

What is a Presidential Reference?

It is a request by the President under Article 143 asking the Supreme Court for its opinion on an important question of law or fact. The opinion is advisory.

Is there a time limit for the Governor to give assent?

The Constitution does not fix a time limit, and the November 2025 opinion said courts cannot impose one. But the Governor must act within a reasonable time.

For more Polity topics in simple language, see our Governor and State Government, President of India and Indian Federalism posts, or browse the Polity section. Preparing for civil services? Start with the UPSC Civil Services guide or join the 100 Hour GS Course.